Carf's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Spooky Mysteries]

confused

Can I please ask what the intension has been of sharing this? I dont think that it would be picked up quickly as for use in an animation... its not really deepgoing... not a lot happends within the 2 minuts of audio... the idea could be way more worked out. make it more spooky, make it compatible wiht one of my ghost houses in RCT3 ;) Please do not feel offended, its just my point of view which I share with you as being a creative person.

iamgrimreaper responds:

This is a good song, you couldv'e at least voted 4 on your review. This doesn't deserve a 0.

[Dumb Windows Song]

Cool idea

Send it to MS, they might use it as an opening sound when windows starts ;).
JK, cool idea behind the track and it is even worked out really cool.
Keep up the fresh ideas and creativity.

[Orchestral Majesty]

Good stuff

I rather see a explanation about your idea behind the track instead of some whoring to get more hits on myspace or your NG music section.... but that is my point of view. I like the track, it fits perfectly on NG and I hope to hear it back in a animation.
Clear strings, lovely, its a hard instrument to handle on a digital way (aswell irl ;p). Keep up the good work.

[But Who Will Save The City]

The name caught my attension ;)

Promising start of the track. Got my intrest already. Altrough I am not the biggest D&B fan, its quiet catchy, would fit well in a MegaMan game or anything like that.
Keep up the good work.

SymbolCymbal responds:

HAHA thanks i think thats one of the reasons the track gets so much attention.
thanks for the review

[Metical - Desertion]

Intresting!

To start off, already a 5 for the effort. I hear a lot of depth and its only at 00.48 secs yet... Very cool theme, it would fit perfectly in a Metal Slug ;).
Keep up the good work.

[Control (dub)]

Art :)

And I like people who try to do things different.
It would have fitted a 100% in Portals.
Cool atmosphere, and I like your lil statement in the comment to.
Keep up the good work.

Sythec responds:

Thanks.
Check out 'Black Angels"

[Waterlight]

Then FINISH IT!

Cause it already sounds more then promising!

Nice flow, and good story telling, it kept my intrest for 3 minuts and its not even ment to be a loop ;).

Keep up the creativity.

S3C responds:

Thanks Carf! I just dont know where to take it :'(

[Yanathrea]

something is missing...

What is it...? Reading your own comment I assume that you are not really proud of it yourself... *finished it early*? Well... my advice would be... work things out before you upload... it gives me the feeling that you rather upload something cause its *cool to have something on your list* then rather work it out before you *really got something that is worthy to upload*. Its... just not finished... its missing creative love...

DJBulwark responds:

I keep getting that I'm missing something, hell even I know something's missing and I have a hard time figuring it out... Kind of discouraging but I figure I should probably work a little more until I find my niche.

Thanks for the review nonetheless though!

[Desert Flare]

a 5

for the amazingly cool drum.
For the rest... it did not really kept my intrest...

S3C responds:

well atleast you liked the drums :P

Thanks for the review!

[Rain Waltz]

Nice atmosphere.

Cool - Scary - Cold - Shiver - I am with ya!

Would fit perfectly in a ghosthouse in Rollercoaster tycoon...
Wut... I think that if I going to get in one of my RCT periods... I actually
might use it ;)

8-4+fave!

Keep up the creativity.