Carf's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Ominous City]

Hope the city survives then...

You love the reverb dont ya ;).
I wont call it hiphop, its more ambient stylish. Altrough I am not blown away, it still defenetly got a vibe, and that is what its all about.

Sasha-William responds:

Thanks buddy. Yeah, I wasn't too sure what category this fitted into so I made my decision based on the inclusion of the drum machines. You know what, I'll change the category from old school hip-hop to ambient. I appreciate the suggestion.

[Lejin - Mercy(that wut u want)]

fail

very bad recording of vocal, it just does not fit the beat. learn how to record otherwise... you will keep on getting blamed and flamed i am afraid.... 3 for the effort...

Lejin responds:

YEAH!!! Thats the kind of review i expect from a pansy with a pink sweater XD

COTDayyyyM the truth HURTS KID!

http://img501.imageshack.us/img501/45 9/pinksweaterrj5.jpg (Delete the space in the link)

<<BANG>>KO!!!

[.Synthetic Symphony.]

hmmmmmzzzz nopes...

sorry to say man but its just... nothing special in particulair... I dont digg the melody, the style itself is just... it sounds like searching for something but you dont have figured out what it is yet. Keep on trying would be my advice...

Yabossobay responds:

well, thanks for the advice i guess

[(NUB)Pulling Through [8bit]]

I LOVE 8BIT

I always admire people who are trying to make 8bitz sounds, the only thing I would like to hear back is a drum which is also 8bit itself, otherwise its just like a very old car with brand new wheels... sorry lame example but I am sure you catch the drift. keep up the good work.

nubbinownz responds:

hehe all the drums up until the end are 8bit thank you so much :D

[Imminent Danger]

I hope they appriciate...

song sounds okay, nothing spectaculair but absolutely not bad. Sounds are okay, arragement is build up nice, just keep up the good work.

dogukakugi responds:

Salamat po (thanks). That means a lot coming from an experienced musician like you.

[FF7-Those Who Fight (Pian]

its...

Complicated... LOL still I like.

**This took me HOURS to get all the notes down. BUT i finally did it lol.**
Does this mean you have put this in a grid completely... that IS a hellofa job!!!

DJ-Nightmare responds:

If I could take a guess it was about 3000 notes I had to put down. So yea. Thats why it took me so long.

[SMB - Rockin' Fun]

a 0 for originality...

just because this is one of the most copied track ever...

Thomas responds:

Doesn't mean it's bad.Most of anything in the Video Game genre could get 0's from you if you base your entire review off of originality.

Obviously if you can't enjoy all of the covers of this song,you must not have a taste in Super Mario music.

[Eye for an eye]

this was.... a lot of work.

after reading your own comment I can so imagine where you are comming from.
Now that has been said, up to the track.
I am making digital music for a long long time and I think that I got a pretty good view on how arrangements would look like, I can only say one thing, I KNOW that this track has been a hell of a job. Its a very, very creative mess which cleans itself up at the very same time ;) I hope you catch my words within this cause its just how it feels for me. It keeps on changing, altrough it doesnt really got a mainline, still you know exactly how to keep it flowing AND at the same time keep it intresting. Keep up the good work, I hear a lot of potential ;).

WarlordXMaster responds:

Thank you very much for the in depth comment. I will keep it in mind for my next piece, thank you. =)

[SkyFly!]

happy vibes!

It seems that you are really proud of your own work so i will keep my review clean.
Basicly the overall track is quiet alive already, lots of things are happening, but the issue is that its only within one line, the higher sounds.
There is no variation in bass, kicks, highheads. Maybe a vocal would add already a lot to give this idea a bit more vibe.
overall its not bad, I assume that you are playing around with music programs for not that long now, but I see potention.
Learn how to bring variatie in a track and digg deeper, you wont regret it ;).

eXite responds:

Yep :P

Ty! And ye.. I'm a Noob ^^

[Project Bluebook]

Gamestylish!

Do you remember the game *forsaken* (ps1 N64 and pc) believe me, it would have been a great song for that game.
Good atmosphere, ambient is not an easy genre.
Keep up the good work

Akaliko responds:

Can't say that I do, but thanks for the compliment. I really appreciate the feedback.